James Wirrell: A Response To Communion Matters

From here:

The final section offers several questions for reflection. I will offer my responses to these questions in light of my comments above.

How can the Episcopal Church affirm and strengthen these precious bonds?

I think that the best way in which we can affirm and strengthen the bonds of fellowship to the Anglican Communion is to honestly, decisively and forthrightly meet and implement the requests of the Dar Es Salaam Communiqué. This may not be what many in TEC want right now, but it is the only way forward to maintain true unity in the Anglican Communion. To do anything else is to cause untold damage to a precious gift of God.

How is the gift of communion manifested through diversity today?

The Anglican Communion is diverse in many, many ways, and I believe that this diversity is one of the Communion’s greatest gifts. I think that what must be remembered is that the issue is not about diversity. Rather it is about what the outer boundaries of diversity of doctrine and discipline are.

Can we find in the midst of our current diversity of theological and cultural “language” a deeper unity in Christ—not “a compromise for the sake of peace, but a comprehension for the sake of truth”?

As explained above, as it relates to human sexuality, I believe that Lambeth Resolution 1.10 is an excellent example of this.

What makes it possible for us to live with differences and maintain the Anglican “middle way”?

Is it possible that our witness today might be to hold to the via media and remain in communion despite what at present seem diametrically opposed positions? Might our gift to the world be the ability to embody Paul’s word to the Corinthians: that one part of the body cannot say to the other, “I have no need of you,” nor can one part say “I am not needed”?

Communion is only possible when all parties agree to submit to a mutual accountability and correction. It makes no sense for TEC to act unilaterally in some areas while protesting similar unilateral actions by others. Our gift to the world is when we adhere to the Communion teaching and discipline, even if we do not agree with it, and seek to change minds in a prayerful, godly, honest, upfront, and non-political manner.

Are we called to live in mutual forbearance in the midst of similar differences long enough for the faith community to discern God’s will?

We are called to submit to the current Communion discernment on doctrine and discipline even as we might seek a further discernment of God’s will.

Some suggest we have reached an impasse, with seemingly “irreconcilable differences.” If so, how then might we live together confident of Jesus’ promise that the Church will endure for eternity?

If majority of TEC’s bishops and dioceses are unable to live within Communion boundaries as they relate to doctrine and discipline, then I believe that this should be openly and honestly acknowledged, and a creative way found to permit for alternative jurisdictions. I believe that an appropriate way forward would be to permit those dioceses that are able to live within Communion boundaries to form together into one jurisdiction, while those dioceses unable to remain Anglican, to form into a separate jurisdiction. Then parishes and clergy who are at odds with their dioceses’ choices could realign, such that in the end, there are two jurisdictions. This division ought to be done in a spirit of graciousness and cooperation, and some ties could remain between the two bodies, such as the pension fund.

A church that is rent asunder by anger, suspicion, lawsuits and harassment is a church that will never heal. On the other hand, a church that maturely acknowledges its differences and decides to split in a spirit of cooperation and goodwill is a church that just might unite again when the underlying issues change.

How might we live this wisdom in the life of the Episcopal Church and the Anglican Communion in this moment?

The problem within the Anglican Communion currently is not a diversity of opinion. There would be nothing wrong with advocating the acceptance of homosexual behavior if TEC continued to adhere to the Communion discipline. Similarly, there is nothing wrong with the Sydney diocese in Australia advocating for lay presidency at the Eucharist provided that they do not act in opposition to Communion discipline. The problem is when one Province unilaterally decides to ignore Communion discipline.

Accordingly, the wise course of action in the Anglican Communion would be for each Province to adhere to the mind of the Communion in regards to discipline and decisions. As time goes on, the Communion discernment on the issue of sexuality might change. But it might not. There is always room for disagreement. There is, however, no room for one Province to simply ignore the Communion doctrine and discipline and expect the rest of the Communion to do nothing.

Friday Pallate Cleanser: REM – Bad Day

Music and video right here.

Important to remember that REM’s first rehearsal spot was an abandoned Episcopal Church. ‘Nuff said. At least something good came of it.

R.E.M. – Bad Day

A public service announcement followed me home the other day.
I paid it nevermind. Go Away.
Shits so thick you could stir it with a stick-free Teflon whitewashed presidency.
We’re sick of being jerked around.
Wear that on your sleeve.

Broadcast me a joyful noise unto the times, lord,
Count your blessings.
We’re sick of being jerked around.
We all fall down.

Have you ever seen the televised St. vitus subcommittee prize
Investigation dance? Those ants in pants glances.
Well,look behind the eyes.
It’s a hallowed hollow anesthetized
“save my own ass, screw these guys”
smoke and mirror lock down.

Broadcast me a joyful noise unto the times, lord,
Count your blessings.
The Papers wouldn’t lie!
I sigh, Not one more.

It’s been a bad day.
Please don’t take a picture.
It’s been a bad day.
Please.

We’re dug in deep the price is steep.
The auctioneer is such a creep.

The lights went out, the oil ran dry
We blamed it on the other guy
Sure, all men are created equal.
Heres the church, heres the steeple
Please stay tuned-we cut to sequel
ashes, ashes, we all fall down.

Broadcast me a joyful noise unto the times, lord,
Count your blessings.
Ignore the lower fear
Ugh, this means war.

It’s been a bad day.
Please don’t take a picture.
It’s been a bad day.
Please.

Broadcast me a joyful noise unto the times, lord,
Count your blessings.
We’re sick of being jerked around.
We all fall down.

It’s been a bad day…

Thoughts On This Week’s News

Well, things may be looking up for this vulture. With the tightening of credit all around, it looks like will have a new Chapter 11 cycle…at least that is what I am predicting. So, Scott Purdy and I will likely be busy with things other than church in the next two to three years. As if I haven’t been busy lately. It is disturbing seeing emails come in predicting a Chapter 11 cycle and then thinking, okay, if a big Chapter 11 or a big fraudulent conveyance defense case walked in the door, how are you going to handle this?

LSU stomped Mississippi State last night. The Town Talk ran a story “Interceptionville” recounting the 35 to nutin’ victory for the Tigers. I caught the game first in the car on XM 200 and then on ESPN. It sure was weird watching college ball on a Thursday. I predict LSU’s toughest game during the regular season will be Alabama on November 3. However, the Virginia Tech game, while not an SEC game, ought to be a good one to watch next week. I think Mississippi State will have to beat Tulane next week or the Bulldog’s coach will get fired.

Yeah, I know. You didn’t come here to read any of this.

So, what’s happening in the Anglican world? All manner of things, not the least of which is the consecration of more bishops for the United States by African Provinces. Lots of bishops there, including Duncan and Iker, and Bishop Nazir-Ali of the Church of England welcomed the consecrations as did Drexel Gomez, Primate of the West Indies.

However, I think my good friend Andrew Carey, whom I had the pleasure of meeting at GC2006, has more or less hit it on the head about the confusion all this creates. As Americans, we are infamously impatient. However, the rest of the Anglican world is ridiculously slow in resolving the presenting issues. So, I agree with Andrew that what is happening with further consecrations of bishops for the United States by other African Provinces is unfortunate, impatient, and creates confusion. I disagree with him that there was much else that could be done under the circumstances since the Executive Council and the House of Bishops have effectively rejected the Pastoral Council and Primatial Vicar scheme proposed in the Dar-es-Salaam Communique. Considering just how intransigent the Episcopal Church is towards the rest of the Anglican Communion, I have a real hard time blaming those involved in the recent consecrations. Do I wish it hadn’t happened? Sure. Do I have any optimism that the House of Bishops will provide pastoral oversight, both Primatial and Episcopal, acceptable to those who in good conscience disagree with the decisions of General Convention and the stances and actions of their bishops and their Primate? Nope.

The only question, for me, is whether the House of Bishops will do anything at all to comply with the requests of the Primates before September 30. I hope and pray they will, but I have very little faith in these bishops, past performance being the best indicator of future performance. Jordan Hylden, someone with whom I correspond by email, recently wrote this article for First Things and I couldn’t describe the situation better myself. He writes:

In many ways, these bishops—the so-called “Camp Allen” and “Windsor” bishops of the Episcopal Church—are at the heart of what will happen next. At next month’s meeting in New Orleans, they will almost certainly lead an attempt to pass resolutions in unequivocal support of the requests made in Tanzania. Conservative divisions, which have become manifest in recent disputes over the direction of Bishop Duncan’s “Network,” will at that point not matter. Despite their many differences of opinion, the entire spectrum represented at the most recent Camp Allen meeting will almost certainly stand together.

Will it work? And if it doesn’t, will Anglicanism fall apart afterwards? It is precisely this that falls in large part to Rowan Williams to decide. He and he alone is in charge of issuing invitations to Lambeth, and so in the end he is the one who will determine whether or not Anglicanism coheres or dissolves. If he tells the Episcopal bishops that their response to decisions made in common by Anglicans indeed will result in concrete consequences for their place in Anglican common life, then much hope remains for a true renewal of Anglican communion.

If not, then the unraveling of the fabric of Anglicanism will continue. Many wonder whether Williams’ intentions thus far have been favorable to those who wish to see the authority of scripture upheld and the catholicity of Anglicanism maintained. At present, many such are unsure that they have his support, even while many liberals wonder likewise about his adherence to their own cause. Thus Williams has become a sort of Rorschach inkblot, in which very smart people on all sides have seen very different intentions displayed. This is why the Camp Allen bishops, in their most recent meeting, asked that Williams would clearly state that Lambeth invitations for the American bishops are at stake in their decision.

If he does so—which will take nothing more than a statement to the effect that, as he previously indicated in his initial letter, invitations to Lambeth will depend upon a demonstrated willingness to abide by the decisions previously made there, without which the trust and cooperation necessary for such a conference will not exist—then it will make a world of difference. Many North American conservatives, currently pondering whether or not to join up with CANA or AMiA, will hold back, reassured that they have not been forgotten. Many in the Global South will do the same, as indeed archbishops Akinola and Orombi have indicated in their recent published essays. Lambeth will go ahead as planned, with the vast majority (save for a small cohort of Gene Robinson supporters) of Anglican bishops present, and the continuing process of covenant and ever-greater coherence will be maintained.

At bottom it will due to the reaffirmation by Williams that there is such a thing as an Anglican Communion; that it consists of forgiven and repentant sinners who, as Archbishop Michael Ramsey reminded us in his classic work The Gospel and the Catholic Church, have died to self and therefore find themselves born anew into the one body of Christ, which is the Church. In such a body words like “independence” and “autonomy” have no meaning, for as St. Paul taught us, the Gospel means that we have died and our lives are hid with Christ in God. We are utterly dependent upon the Body, for our lives and for our salvation, and so in all humility we seek one-mindedness in Christ, who prayed that we might all be one even as he and his Father are one.

It is in a way fitting that this task should fall to the archbishop of Canterbury, who sits in the chair of St. Augustine where all this began in England over a thousand years ago. No doubt those who hope for the renewal of Anglicanism will keep Rowan Williams in their prayers. And no doubt God, in his providence, will remain faithful to those who show themselves faithful, no matter how dark the road may become in the days ahead.

Amen.

A blessed Labor Day weekend to everyone out there. I am going to be cooking up a storm and being with family on Monday and the Iron Skillet competition occurs after a two year hiatus. I wonder what the secret ingredient will be?

Peter Ould’s Open Message To The House of Bishops of TEC

Click here.

Teaching Starts Again Tomorrow Night

Monday night business law class at Louisiana College.  I can’t wait to hear the first complaint from a student about Monday Night Football conflicting with my class.

Thoughts On The Last Reconciliation & Healing Roadshow In Western Louisiana

Well, the five meetings on reconciliation and healing in the Diocese of Western Louisiana are completed. It has been a lot of Saturdays on the road; it was nice to just drive down to my local parish to give my talk. The presentation went well today; the bishop commented that I had a good rhythm in my presentation today (which does vary since I am working from notes). A couple of folks have asked that I put the presentation on DVD. I might just do that.

However, +Bruce and my father let it be known that this is not over. This is just the first stage in finding a way forward for our Diocese. Reconciliation from within is to keep us united so we can chart a direction together, as I’ve written earlier. Now, I think, will come some process of discernment in the post-September 30 Anglican world, particularly if the House of Bishops rejects the Primates’ Communique and Schedule from Tanzania. So, the team was told to be on the lookout for any letters in cream colored envelopes with purple lettering that are addressed to us personally, no label (which would indicate a much larger mailing than this will be.)

All in all, though, the five meetings probably included over 600 members of the Diocese. I think that is a tremendous success.

One of the things I think that truly made this work was that it was not put on by hired guns or folks from outside of the Diocese, so there was an increased level of trust towards those presenting the program.

A couple of folks have asked that I make a DVD of my presentation. I may very well do that. I might even add to it to discuss what the House of Bishops does at their next meeting.

Oh My Goodness…

Rich Anglican Fudge With Nuts is back.

Episcopal Church Proposes Merge with Buddhism. Dali Lama “Rejects” Idea

From here:

Episcopal Church Proposes Merge with Buddhism. Dali Lama “Rejects” Idea

Bullhead City, AZ – Emotions were high again on Tuesday amongst members of the Anglican Church at large. The reactions from both conservatives and liberals within the troubled fellowship were prompted by the suggestion by Katharine Jefferts Schori, the current presiding Bishop of the United Episcopal Church in America, that the church merge with Buddhism. The statement comes in the midst of controversy among Anglicans worldwide as to whether fellowship with the American branch of Anglicanism should be severed due to pervading liberal trends.

“The similarities between our two religions are striking” said Schori to a congregation during a special service in Bullhead City held in honor of her visit. “I have heard the Dali Lama preach a number of times. I read the words of Confucius, and they strike my soul. Buddhism teaches peace with all life, as does the Episcopal Church. Buddhism teaches respect for all things, as do we. Buddhism teaches love, tolerance and patience, and so do we. In all, I believe it would befit us to explore an avenue of bringing our two religions together into one.”

Reactions were strong from both sides of the church.

“This is exactly where Christianity needs to be heading, to Buddhism” stated former Bishop of Newark John Shelby Spong. “In order for Christianity to survive we have to do away with it completely and become Buddhists. All of this Jesus stuff has got to stop.”

“Now we understand why more and more faithful believers are seeking to break with the the UEC in America” stated Rev. Roy Lainer, the rector of Trinity Church in Birmingham, Alabama. “There’s nothing remotely Christian about the denomination anymore.”

While the suggestion caused division amongst an already divided denomination, reactions were heightened with the suggestion to merge was criticized by the Dali Lama himself.

TBNN was able to reach the Dali Lama for an exclusive phone interview concerning the matter. TBNN’s own Brother Slawson personally conducted the interview due to his fluency in the Lama’s particular Mongolian dialect.

Brother Slawson: “Mr. Lama, or do you prefer to be called Dali or Dali Lama?”
Dali Lama: “My friends call me Georgie, but Mr. Lama will be fine.”

Brother Slawson: “Fine, Mr. Lama, what is your response to Bishop Schori’s suggestion that the United Episcopal Church merge with Buddhism?”

Mr. Lama: “Spices are fine things. One puts salt on rice and it will not be bland. One may put curry and it will become more flavorful. But too many spices will make the rice inedible.”

Brother Slawson: “Um, I see, so let me ask that another way. How do you feel about Bishop Schori’s suggestion that Episcopals in America and Buddhists become one.”

Mr. Lama: “The flavor of the apple is good. It’s sweetness makes one smile. The flavor of the onion is good. But it’s sweetness makes one cry. Man must both smile and cry over sweet things, but he cannot do so at the same time.”

Brother Slawson: “Ummm…okay. Whose your pick to win the world series?”

Mr. Lama: “Cubs baby. Woo hoo!”

Brother Slawson: “Thank you Mr. Lama.”

TBNN attempted to reach Schori for an interview but she was “unavailable” for questions. TBNN will continue to monitor the situation.

Minding The Generation Gap In The Anglican Blogosphere

Sometimes, I just get hit with moments of clarity. I was writing an email to a person in the Diocese and a reader of this blog about the reconciliation process in the Diocese and my presentation, what that person thought of it, and so on. In any event, in trying to encapsulate into words that the current controversies in the Episcopal Church and the Anglican Communion had very little to do with sexuality despite the fact that most folks think this is the case, I decided that the controversy really has to do with who Jesus is, the authority of scripture, and the Global South and Generation-X giving the liberal baby boomer mostly lilly white elitist Episcopal Church a good dose of “what for”.

Generation-X is a pretty fluid term. In the broadest definition, Generation-X encompasses folks born from 1960 to 1979.

Take a look at the Anglican blogosphere. Kendall Harmon, for example, was born in 1960. I was born in 1971. I don’t know when, exactly, Sarah Hey, Matt Kennedy, the Ould brothers, Binky, Mike the CaNNet ninja, the Confessing Reader, Baby Blue, and Greg Griffith were born, but I have hung out with them a good bit and we are all in the same generation, that being Generation-X.

On the “other” side of the Anglican blogosphere are hard core baby boomers like Mark Harris, Elizabeth Kaeton, Jan Nunley, and Jim Naughton.

Coincidence?

Well, there is Sarah Dylan Breuer. Definitely a Gen-Xer. The conservative Anglican blogosphere’s favorite liberal, with whom many fruitful discussions are had on StandFirm and her blog by conservatives. The liberal lady who promotes biblical literacy and thinks pew bibles are a good idea in your average Episcopal Church. Why does Dylan even visit places like my blog and StandFirm to dialogue and why is she so well liked, respected, and understood? Well, she is chatting with her fellow Gen-Xers.

Coincidence?

I say all this to say things I’ve said before. Generation-X really isn’t all that interested in re-inventing the Episcopal Church from a faith or liturgy perspective. Frankly, considering the wing-nutty times we grew up in along with some of the wing-nutty baby boomers with whom we’ve had to contend as parents, teachers, preachers and leaders (depending on who you are and where you have been), we’d like a little bit of stability, please, and we are really interested in walking in a more traditional way. Further, we really believe this stuff about Jesus being the way, the truth, the life, that He died for our sins, and so on. Otherwise, we’d not be in church, at all. We aren’t real impressed with the Spongian-Borgian church, can’t really tell the difference between that and the ever so popular Swedenborgian church, and aren’t really impressed with the desire to have a church that baby-boomer liberals can belong to while denying everything that their parents believed and put stock in. The church is way bigger than that.

Oh, and as I’ve mentioned before, Nashotah House has the youngest student body of any seminary in the Episcopal Church, which before had been viewed by the Episcopal Church as that strange little small high church seminary, as that body is made up of a bunch of Generation-Xers with small children and so they have this great children’s choir now, family student housing, and so on.

Coincidence?

But, there is one new point to make.

While the real battle in Anglicanism in the USA is probably among various members of the silent generation and the boomers, as they are of the age to be power-brokers in this struggle, if you look at who is really trying to speak out and make a difference in this “new” media called the internet, it ain’t them, and the voice is conservative and orthodox, even on the liberal end, compared to where things are now.

Coincidence?

I think not.

But, I could be wrong. Tell me what you think…

High Church Trash Talk